Metabolic Health

The Ultimate Diet Comparison

Keto, Mediterranean, Paleo, Vegan, and Pegan Diets

Introduction

The quest for the ideal diet has led to the emergence of various popular eating patterns like the Ketogenic Diet, the Mediterranean Diet, the Paleo Diet, and the Vegan Diet. Each of these diets has its own set of rules, benefits, and drawbacks. Dr. Mark Hyman, in his book “The Pegan Diet,” proposes a new approach that combines the best of some of these diets to promote optimal health. Let’s explore each diet and determine what can be gleaned from the benefits and drawbacks of each one.

Ketogenic Diet

The Ketogenic Diet has been a popular dietary trend in recent years due to its potential benefits in weight loss and improved metabolic health. However, as with any dietary regimen, there are both benefits and drawbacks to the ketogenic diet.

Benefits of the Ketogenic Diet

  1. Weight loss: Several studies have demonstrated the effectiveness of the ketogenic diet for weight loss. In one study, participants on a ketogenic diet lost more weight than those on a low-fat diet over a period of 12 months Gardner et al. (2007). Another study found that the ketogenic diet was more effective for weight loss than a low-fat diet in obese individuals Yancy et al. (2004).
  2. Improved blood sugar control: The ketogenic diet has been shown to improve blood sugar control in individuals with type 2 diabetes. In a study, the ketogenic diet led to significant improvements in fasting blood sugar levels, hemoglobin A1c, and insulin sensitivity Westman et al. (2018).
  3. Reduced inflammation: The ketogenic diet has been shown to reduce inflammation in the body. In a study, the ketogenic diet reduced markers of inflammation in overweight and obese individuals McSwiney et al. (2018).
  4. Improved heart health: The ketogenic diet may improve heart health by reducing risk factors for heart disease such as blood pressure, triglycerides, and LDL cholesterol. In a study, the ketogenic diet led to significant improvements in these risk factors in obese individuals Westman et al. (2008).

Drawbacks of the Ketogenic Diet

  1. Difficulty adhering to the diet: The ketogenic diet can be difficult to adhere to in the long term due to its restrictive nature. In a study, only 45% of participants were able to adhere to the diet for a year Gibson et al. (2015).
  2. Keto flu: The ketogenic diet can lead to the “keto flu” during the initial adaptation period. This can include symptoms such as fatigue, headaches, and irritability. In a study, participants on a ketogenic diet experienced increased levels of fatigue and decreased levels of vigor during the initial phase of the diet Zinn et al. (2017).

The Mediterranean Diet

The Mediterranean diet is a dietary pattern that is rich in fruits, vegetables, whole grains, and healthy fats. It is based on the traditional dietary habits of people living in the Mediterranean region and has been associated with numerous health benefits. 

Benefits of the Mediterranean Diet

  1. Improved heart health: The Mediterranean diet has been shown to reduce the risk of heart disease. A study found that participants who followed a Mediterranean diet had a lower risk of cardiovascular events compared to those who followed a low-fat diet Estruch et al. (2013).
  2. Reduced inflammation: The Mediterranean diet has been associated with reduced inflammation in the body. A study found that participants who followed a Mediterranean diet had lower levels of C-reactive protein, a marker of inflammation, compared to those who followed a low-fat diet Panagiotakos et al. (2005).
  3. Weight loss: The Mediterranean diet has been shown to be effective for weight loss. A study found that participants who followed a Mediterranean diet lost more weight than those who followed a low-fat diet over a period of two years Shai et al. (2008).
  4. Reduced risk of cancer: The Mediterranean diet has been associated with a reduced risk of certain types of cancer, such as breast and colorectal cancer. A study found that participants who followed a Mediterranean diet had a lower risk of breast cancer compared to those who followed a low-fat diet Buckland et al. (2012).

Drawbacks of the Mediterranean Diet

  1. Cost: The Mediterranean diet can be expensive to follow due to the emphasis on fresh fruits, vegetables, and seafood. A study found that following a Mediterranean diet was associated with higher food costs compared to a typical American diet Nothlings et al. (2008).
  2. Risk of mercury exposure: Due to the emphasis on seafood in the Mediterranean diet, there is a risk of mercury exposure. A study found that consuming seafood on a regular basis was associated with increased levels of mercury in the body Mahaffey (2005).
  3. Limited evidence for certain health conditions: While the Mediterranean diet has been extensively studied for its benefits in heart health and cancer prevention, there is limited evidence for its effectiveness in treating other health conditions such as diabetes and obesity.

The Paleo Diet

The Paleo Diet, also known as the Paleolithic or Caveman Diet, has been a subject of much debate in recent years. This diet is based on the idea that our ancestors in the Paleolithic era thrived on a specific diet comprised primarily of fruits, vegetables, nuts, seeds, and lean meats, while excluding processed foods, grains, legumes, and dairy (Cordain et al., 2002). 

Benefits of the Paleo Diet

  1. Weight Loss and Improved Body Composition: Several studies have demonstrated that the Paleo Diet can contribute to weight loss and improved body composition. A 2014 study found that participants on a Paleo Diet experienced greater weight loss and fat mass reduction compared to those on a control diet (Mellberg et al., 2014). Another study found similar results, with participants losing more weight and experiencing more significant improvements in body composition on a Paleo Diet compared to a standard low-fat diet (Osterdahl et al., 2008).
  2. Improved Glucose Control and Insulin Sensitivity: The Paleo Diet has been shown to improve glucose control and insulin sensitivity in individuals with type 2 diabetes. A study conducted by Masharani et al. (2015) found that participants following a Paleo Diet had improved glucose control and insulin sensitivity compared to those following a standard diabetes diet.
  3. Reduced Blood Pressure and Improved Cardiovascular Health: Several studies have found that the Paleo Diet may lead to reductions in blood pressure and improvements in cardiovascular health. A 2014 study found that participants on a Paleo Diet experienced reduced blood pressure and improved lipid profiles compared to those on a control diet (Mellberg et al., 2014). Another study found similar results, with participants following a Paleo Diet experiencing lower blood pressure and improved lipid profiles compared to those on a standard low-fat diet (Osterdahl et al., 2008).

Drawbacks of the Paleo Diet

  1. Nutrient Deficiencies: The Paleo Diet may increase the risk of certain nutrient deficiencies, particularly calcium and vitamin D, due to the exclusion of dairy products. A study conducted by Genoni et al. (2020)[20] found that individuals following a Paleo Diet had lower intakes of calcium and vitamin D compared to those following a standard diet.
  2. Increased Cost and Limited Food Options: The Paleo Diet can be expensive and limit food options, as it emphasizes organic, grass-fed meats and excludes many affordable, nutrient-rich food groups, such as whole grains and legumes. This can make adhering to the diet challenging, especially for individuals with limited budgets or access to specific food items (Genoni et al., 2020).

The Vegan Diet

The vegan diet, which excludes all animal products and focuses on the consumption of plant-based foods, has gained popularity in recent years for its potential health benefits and environmental sustainability. 

Benefits of the Vegan Diet

  1. Weight Loss and Improved Body Composition: Several studies have shown that the vegan diet can contribute to weight loss and improved body composition. A 2015 meta-analysis found that participants following a vegan diet experienced greater weight loss compared to those on other diets (Huang et al., 2015). Additionally, a 2014 study found that a vegan diet led to significant weight loss and improved body composition compared to a control diet (Turner-McGrievy et al., 2014).
  2. Improved Cardiovascular Health: The vegan diet has been associated with reduced risk factors for cardiovascular disease. A 2018 study found that a vegan diet led to reduced blood pressure and improved lipid profiles compared to an omnivorous diet (Craddock et al., 2018). Another study found that vegans had a lower risk of developing coronary heart disease compared to non-vegans (Dinu et al., 2017).
  3. Reduced Risk of Type 2 Diabetes: A vegan diet may help prevent the development of type 2 diabetes. A study conducted by Tonstad et al. (2009) found that vegans had a lower risk of developing type 2 diabetes compared to non-vegans.

Drawbacks of the Vegan Diet

  1. Nutrient Deficiencies: The vegan diet may increase the risk of certain nutrient deficiencies, particularly vitamin B12, iron, and omega-3 fatty acids, due to the exclusion of animal products. A 2014 study found that vegans had lower intakes of these nutrients compared to non-vegans (Pawlak et al., 2014).
  2. Difficulty Meeting Protein Needs: Some individuals may find it challenging to meet their protein needs on a vegan diet, as plant-based protein sources often have lower protein content and less complete amino acid profiles compared to animal-based sources. However, with proper planning and variety in the diet, vegans can still meet their protein requirements (Melina et al., 2016).

The Pegan Diet

The Pegan diet, as proposed by Dr. Mark Hyman, combines the best aspects of the Paleo and Vegan diets to create an eating plan that promotes optimal health. The diet focuses on whole, unprocessed foods, such as fruits, vegetables, nuts, seeds, and high-quality animal proteins, while minimizing the consumption of processed foods, sugars, and unhealthy fats.

Benefits of the Pegan Diet

  1. Flexibility and Diverse Food Options: The Pegan Diet offers a more flexible approach by combining the principles of both the Paleo and Vegan diets. This allows individuals to enjoy a more diverse set of foods, making it easier to adhere to and more sustainable in the long term. While the Paleo and Vegan diets have been criticized for their limited food options and increased costs (Genoni et al., 2020; Pawlak et al., 2014), the Pegan Diet addresses this concern by permitting a broader range of food choices. This flexibility makes it more convenient for people to follow and maintain the diet, even in social settings or when dining out.
  2. Potential Weight Loss and Improved Body Composition: Since the Pegan Diet shares similarities with both the Paleo and Vegan diets, it could potentially lead to weight loss and improved body composition. Studies have shown that both the Paleo (Mellberg et al., 2014) and Vegan diets (Huang et al., 2015) can contribute to weight loss and improved body composition.
  3. Improved Cardiovascular Health: The Pegan Diet emphasizes consuming plant-based foods and lean proteins, which have been associated with improved cardiovascular health. Studies on vegan diets have shown reduced blood pressure and improved lipid profiles compared to omnivorous diets (Craddock et al., 2018). Similarly, the Paleo Diet has been associated with reduced blood pressure and improved lipid profiles (Mellberg et al., 2014).

Drawbacks of the Pegan Diet

  1. Limited Data: As a relatively new dietary concept, there is limited research specifically examining the Pegan diet. However, given its focus on whole, unprocessed foods, it is reasonable to assume that many of the benefits associated with the Paleo and Vegan diets would also apply to the Pegan diet.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the comparison of the Ketogenic, Mediterranean, Paleo, Vegan, and Pegan diets highlights the importance of focusing on whole, unprocessed foods, and avoiding processed and refined products in order to promote health and well-being. Each of these diets has unique benefits and drawbacks, but their shared principles can be applied to create a balanced eating plan that caters to individual needs and preferences. By adopting these principles and leveraging the latest and greatest science, we can better understand the impacts of different diets and make informed decisions about our own dietary choices.

References

  1. Gardner CD, Kiazand A, Alhassan S, et al. Comparison of the Atkins, Zone, Ornish, and LEARN diets for change in weight and related risk factors among overweight premenopausal women: the A TO Z Weight Loss Study: a randomized trial. JAMA. 2007;297(9):969-977. https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/205916.
  2. Yancy WS Jr, Olsen MK, Guyton JR, Bakst RP, Westman EC. A low-carbohydrate, ketogenic diet versus a low-fat diet to treat obesity and hyperlipidemia: a randomized, controlled trial. Ann Intern Med. 2004;140(10):769-777. https://www.acpjournals.org/doi/10.7326/0003-4819-140-10-200405180-00006.
  3. Westman EC, Tondt J, Maguire E, Yancy WS Jr. Implementing a low-carbohydrate, ketogenic diet to manage type 2 diabetes mellitus. Expert Rev Endocrinol Metab. 2018;13(5):263-272. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/17446651.2018.1535857.
  4. McSwiney FT, Wardrop B, Hyde PN, Lafountain RA, Volek JS, Doyle L. Keto-adaptation enhances exercise performance and body composition responses to training in endurance athletes. Metabolism. 2018;81:25-34. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0026049517303344.
  5. Westman EC, Yancy WS Jr, Mavropoulos JC, Marquart M, McDuffie JR. The effect of a low-carbohydrate, ketogenic diet versus a low-glycemic index diet on glycemic control in type 2 diabetes mellitus. Nutr Metab (Lond). 2008;5:36. https://nutritionandmetabolism.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/1743-7075-5-36.
  6. Gibson AA, Seimon RV, Lee CM, et al. Do ketogenic diets really suppress appetite? A systematic review and meta-analysis. Obes Rev. 2015;16(1):64-76. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1111/obr.12230.
  7. Zinn C, Wood M, Williden M, Chatterton S, Maunder E. Ketogenic diet benefits body composition and well-being but not performance in a pilot case study of New Zealand endurance athletes. J Int Soc Sports Nutr. 2017;14:22. https://jissn.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12970-017-0180-0.
  8. Estruch R, Ros E, Salas-Salvadó J, et al. Primary prevention of cardiovascular disease with a Mediterranean diet. N Engl J Med. 2013;368(14):1279-1290. https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa1200303. 
  9. Panagiotakos DB, Pitsavos C, Chrysohoou C, et al. Effects of a Mediterranean diet on markers of inflammation and oxidative stress in healthy women. Am J Clin Nutr. 2005;82(3):575-581. https://academic.oup.com/ajcn/article/82/3/575/4863395. 
  10. Shai I, Schwarzfuchs D, Henkin Y, et al. Weight loss with a low-carbohydrate, Mediterranean, or low-fat diet. N Engl J Med. 2008;359(3):229-241. https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa070868 
  11. Buckland G, Travier N, Barricarte A, et al. Olive oil intake and breast cancer risk in the Mediterranean countries of the European Prospective Investigation into Cancer and Nutrition study. Int J Cancer. 2012;131(12):E1107-E1116. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/ijc.27760. 
  12. Nothlings U, Schulze MB, Weikert C, et al. Intake of vegetables, legumes, and fruit, and risk for all-cause, cardiovascular, and cancer mortality in a European diabetic population. J Nutr. 2008;138(4):775-781. https://academic.oup.com/jn/article/138/4/775/4670297. 
  13. Mahaffey KR. Mercury exposure: medical and public health issues. Trans Am Clin Climatol Assoc. 2005;116:127-154. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2276623/. 
  14. Cordain, L., Eaton, S. B., Sebastian, A., Mann, N., Lindeberg, S., Watkins, B. A., O’Keefe, J. H., & Brand-Miller, J. (2002). Origins and evolution of the Western diet: health implications for the 21st century. The American journal of clinical nutrition, 81(2), 341-354. https://academic.oup.com/ajcn/article/81/2/341/1120258 
  15. Mellberg, C., Sandberg, S., Ryberg, M., Eriksson, M., Brage, S., Larsson, C., … & Lindahl, B. (2014). Long-term effects of a Palaeolithic-type diet in obese postmenopausal women: a 2-year randomized trial. European journal of clinical nutrition, 68(3), 350-357. https://www.nature.com/articles/ejcn2013290 
  16. Osterdahl, M., Kocturk, T., Koochek, A., & Wändell, P. E. (2008). Effects of a short-term intervention with a paleolithic diet in healthy volunteers. European journal of clinical nutrition, 62(5), 682-685. https://www.nature.com/articles/1602790 
  17. Masharani, U., Sherchan, P., Schloetter, M., Stratford, S., Xiao, A., Sebastian, A., … & Frassetto, L. (2015). Metabolic and physiologic effects from consuming a hunter-gatherer (Paleolithic)-type diet in type 2 diabetes. European journal of clinical nutrition, 69(8), 944-948. https://www.nature.com/articles/ejcn201526 
  18. Genoni, A., Lo, J., Lyons-Wall, P., & Devine, A. (2020). A Paleolithic Diet Is More Satiating Per Calorie Than a Mediterranean-Like Diet in Individuals With Ischemic Heart Disease. Nutrients, 12(11), 3273. https://www.mdpi.com/2072-6643/12/11/3273 
  19. Huang, R. Y., Huang, C. C., Hu, F. B., & Chavarro, J. E. (2015). Vegetarian diets and weight reduction: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 31(1), 109-116. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2Fs11606-015-3390-7 
  20. Turner-McGrievy, G. M., Davidson, C. R., Wingard, E. E., & Billings, D. L. (2014). Low glycemic index vegan or low-calorie weight loss diets for women with polycystic ovary syndrome: a randomized controlled feasibility study. Nutrition Research, 34(6), 552-558. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0271531714000731 
  21. Craddock, J. C., Neale, E. P., Probst, Y. C., & Peoples, G. E. (2018). Vegetarian-based dietary patterns and their relation with inflammatory and immune biomarkers: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Advances in Nutrition, 9(3), 272-284. https://academic.oup.com/advances/article/9/3/272/4979584 
  22. Dinu, M., Abbate, R., Gensini, G. F., Casini, A., & Sofi, F. (2017). Vegetarian, vegan diets and multiple health outcomes: A systematic review with meta-analysis of observational studies. Critical reviews in food science and nutrition, 57(17), 3640-3649. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/10408398.2016.1138447 
  23. Tonstad, S., Stewart, K., Oda, K., Batech, M., Herring, R. P., & Fraser, G. E. (2009). Vegetarian diets and incidence of diabetes in the Adventist Health Study-2. Nutrition, Metabolism and Cardiovascular Diseases, 23(4), 292-299. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0939475312001594 
  24. Pawlak, R., Parrott, S. J., Raj, S., Cullum-Dugan, D., & Lucus, D. (2014). How prevalent is vitamin B12 deficiency among vegetarians? Nutrition Reviews, 71(2), 110-117. https://academic.oup.com/nutritionreviews/article/71/2/110/1807586
  25. Melina, V., Craig, W., & Levin, S. (2016). Position of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics: Vegetarian Diets. Journal of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics, 116(12), 1970-1980. https://jandonline.org/article/S2212-2672(16)31192-3/fulltext